Menu

LLC vs S corp: how each is taxed and what the election changes

LLC vs S corp is not a choice between two kinds of company. An LLC is a legal form created under state law, while an S corporation is a tax status that an LLC can elect for federal tax by filing Form 2553. Without an election, an LLC with one owner is taxed like its owner and an LLC with two or more members as a partnership. With S corporation status, an owner who works in the company and takes money out of it needs reasonable pay with payroll taxes on it, but the rest of the profit carries no self-employment tax; the status is closed to nonresident aliens and has to be elected on time.

  1. How an LLC is taxed by default
  2. S corp vs LLC taxes: what the election changes
  3. The owner’s pay: reasonable compensation
  4. Who cannot be an S corporation
  5. Deadlines: Form 2553 and late relief

How an LLC is taxed by default

An LLC is a business structure allowed by state statute, and the IRS classifies it by the number of members and by the elections the company has made. With one member, an LLC is not separate from its owner for federal income tax: its income goes on the owner’s return, for an individual usually on Schedule C, and the owner pays self-employment tax on net earnings in the same way as a sole proprietorship does.

An LLC with two or more members is by default a partnership: it files Form 1065, the members get a Schedule K-1 with their share and generally pay self-employment tax on their share of the earnings. The classification can be changed with Form 8832, by which an LLC elects to be classified as a corporation, a partnership or an entity disregarded as separate from its owner.

S corp vs LLC taxes: what the election changes

An S corporation is a corporation that elects to pass income, losses, deductions and credits through to its shareholders: they report them on their personal returns and pay tax at their individual rates, while the company itself generally pays no income tax, apart from some kinds of income. An LLC that qualifies makes the election with Form 2553 alone and does not need to file Form 8832. It then files Form 1120-S by the 15th day of the 3rd month after the end of its tax year, and each shareholder gets a K-1 and reports the share on a personal return, whether or not the money was distributed. Unlike most partnership income, S corporation income is not self-employment income and is not subject to self-employment tax.

But new duties come with it: the owner’s wages are subject to employment taxes, reported on Forms 941 and 940, and every year the company also files a separate return with all the K-1s. State taxes follow their own rules and affect the choice too: in California, for example, an LLC pays an $800 annual tax and, with California income above $250,000, a fee starting at $900, while an S corporation pays the $800 minimum franchise tax, and its California-source income is taxed at 1.5%.

The owner’s pay: reasonable compensation

An S corporation must pay a shareholder who works in the company reasonable compensation before making non-wage distributions to them. The IRS looks at training and experience, duties, the time devoted to the business, what the company pays its other employees and what comparable businesses pay for similar services. If payments to a shareholder are called distributions but actually pay for the shareholder’s work, the IRS can reclassify them as wages, which are subject to employment taxes.

So the comparison to make is not “LLC against S corporation” in general but your own numbers: how much profit is left after reasonable pay, what payroll and a second return cost, and what the state charges.

Who cannot be an S corporation

The status has conditions: the company must be domestic, have no more than 100 shareholders and one class of stock, and its shareholders can only be individuals, estates and certain trusts and organizations. Partnerships, corporations and nonresident aliens cannot be shareholders. The IRS treats someone as a nonresident for tax purposes if they are not a US citizen and meet neither the green card test nor the substantial presence test. The second test is met by being in the US at least 31 days in the current year and at least 183 days over three years, counting all the days of the current year, a third of the days of the year before and a sixth of the year before that. Some days do not count: for example, the days of a student on an F, J, M or Q visa who complies with the visa’s requirements are generally exempt for up to 5 calendar years.

If a nonresident alien becomes a shareholder, or the company stops meeting another condition of the law, the status terminates from the day that happened. Such an LLC stays classified as a corporation, now an ordinary C corporation, until it makes a valid election of another classification on Form 8832. What an LLC with a foreign owner files is described on the page about company formation.

Deadlines: Form 2553 and late relief

Form 2553 is filed no more than 2 months and 15 days after the beginning of the tax year the election is to take effect, or at any time during the tax year before it. For status from January 1, 2027, for example, the form can be filed during 2026 or by March 15, 2027. A new company has no earlier year, so the form cannot be filed before its first day. All the shareholders sign the form, and the IRS’s answer usually comes within 60 days. The election stays in effect until it is revoked or terminated; another election for any tax year before the 5th tax year after the first year in which the revocation or termination took effect generally needs the IRS’s consent.

If the deadline was missed, the election can sometimes be made late, within 3 years and 75 days of the date it was meant to take effect. The company must have intended to be an S corporation from that date, must have missed the status only because the form was late and must have reasonable cause, and all the shareholders must confirm they reported income as S corporation shareholders. If the conditions are not met, what is left is a private letter ruling from the IRS, for a fee.

We file Form 2553 for $100, $150 when late, and prepare Form 1120-S returns: a zero return $300, $750 with revenue up to $250,000, and $900 above that. A reasonable compensation report costs $150. Whether an S corporation suits you can be worked through in the Tax & Business Consultation: 45 minutes, $200.

Questions and answers

Which is better for taxes, an LLC or an S corporation?

They are not two kinds of company: an LLC is formed under state law, while S corporation status is elected for federal tax, and an LLC can elect it. Which is better depends on the profit left after reasonable pay for the owner, on the cost of payroll and a second return, and on state taxes. Without an election, an LLC with one owner is taxed like its owner and an LLC with two or more members as a partnership.

Can an LLC become an S corporation?

Yes, if it is a domestic company with no more than 100 shareholders, only eligible shareholders with no nonresident aliens, and one class of stock. It files Form 2553, signed by all the shareholders; Form 8832 does not have to be filed separately. Once the IRS accepts the election, the company files Form 1120-S.

Can a nonresident own an S corporation?

No: an S corporation cannot have a nonresident alien as a shareholder. For tax purposes someone is a nonresident if they are not a US citizen and meet neither the green card test nor the substantial presence test. If a nonresident alien becomes a shareholder, S corporation status terminates from the day the company stopped meeting the conditions.

What is the deadline for Form 2553?

No more than 2 months and 15 days after the beginning of the tax year the election is to take effect, or at any time during the tax year before it. For status from January 1, 2027, for example, that is during 2026 or by March 15, 2027. If the deadline was missed, the election can sometimes be made late, within 3 years and 75 days, if the conditions are met.

Does the owner of an S corporation have to pay themselves a salary?

Yes, if they work in the company and take money out of it: an S corporation must pay a shareholder-employee reasonable compensation before making non-wage distributions, and payroll taxes are paid on it. If payments are called distributions but pay for the work, the IRS can reclassify them as wages.

Sources

This article explains general rules and does not replace advice on your own situation, which may differ.

Read next

Leave a request

Tell us what you need, and we will call you back.

Request sent

We will call or write back.

Close

We will call or write back

Do not include an SSN or ITIN. Documents go through the client portal

Privacy policy

A free 15-minute call

We briefly go over your situation, which of our services fit and how to start. The call is free for new clients; it is an introduction, not a tax consultation.